OK, Let's Be Clear on What 'Brain Dead' Means...
Got to make a point here, because the Vanity Fair idiot just interviewed on "Hardball" is obviously clueless. While I take his side in this issue, I find that he and many others on the same side are often being factually incorrect in defining their terms. This doesn't help anybody.
So let's be clear. Whatever else Shiavo is, she is not "brain dead" by any standard medical definition. Those people on the "right to life" side of this discussion are correct in that she is -- medically -- "brain damaged," but not dead.
To be declared brain dead, a person's entire brain function must cease. This includes brain stem functions such as breathing, reflexive actions and heartbeat. A brain dead person will die immediately without artifical respiration and/or circulation. This definition is important only in very limited circumstances, particularly where there is a desire to harvest organs for donation.
For Terri Shiavo, as was the case for my father some time back, the issue is not brain death. Rather it is dealing with an individual whose conscious brain is gone, even as the body's automatic functions continue.
It is a difficult situation precisely because the brain is not dead, but instead remains in a grey area -- functioning automatically, but having lost the essence of the person we knew.



